Bullet News
But Michael Chan brokers second meeting with Niagara Parks Commission
JOHN ROBBINS and PETER CONRADI/Bullet News
NIAGARA FALLS – Ontario Tourism Minister Michael Chan has told wirewalker Nik Wallenda he doesn’t have the legal authority to overturn a Niagara Parks Commission decision denying his request for permission to wirewalk the Niagara Gorge.
The minister has instead spoken to NPC chairwoman Janice Thomson to encourage the provincial agency to give Wallenda another chance to make his pitch in greater detail.
“I think he’s a passionate person and a person who doesn’t easily give up,” Chan, who called Wallenda’s proposal “very interesting,” told Bullet News Friday afternoon.
“I made it very clear to him I don’t have the power under the (Niagara Parks) Act to overturn the NPC decision.”
Far from being dismayed, Wallenda said he emerged from the 1 1/2 hour, face-to-face meeting with Chan at Queen’s Park with a renewed feeling of optimism.
“I feel like we’re going to get our fair shot again,” said Wallenda, who was preparing to catch a flight back to his home in Sarasota, Fla.
“It (the meeting) went very well. It was extremely positive. He clearly understood our position…. I feel like the doors are wide open again.”
In another development Friday, though, the New York State Parks has come out against Wallenda’s so-called Plan B of walking across the American falls if he cannot secure permission from the Canadians.
In a statement, Commissioner Rose Harvey said the department won’t support the high-wire act limited only to the American side of the falls or other alternatives to his planned international tightrope walk.
In September, New York Gov. Andrew Cuomo approved legislation authorizing the state parks department to allow Wallenda special permission to make the 1,800-foot walk beginning on the New York side of the falls. Canadian approval was needed for the walk’s end near the Table Rock visitor centre.
“A walk limited to the American Falls is not what New York approved or envisioned in legislation authorizing Nik Wallenda to traverse the Niagara River Gorge from the United States to Canada,” Harvey’s statement said.
“The costs to New York State of managing a walk only across the American Falls would exceed $1 million in direct state expenses, while, because of the physical topography of Niagara Falls and crowd safety concerns, the number of people who could watch such a walk would be extremely limited. As a result, despite the costs to New York State, the vast majority of people on the U.S. side would be turned away from the park and never see the walk.”
New York State Sen. George Maziarz told Bullet News Friday evening he was surprised about the timing of the Parks announcement. He said his interpretation is that New York Parks would want to go back and take a closer look at plans for a walk over the American falls, not that it is issuing an outright condemnation of the proposal. But Maziarz is still hopeful that Ontario will give Wallenda the OK.
“I’m hearing that the meeting (with Chan) went very well,” he said. “I think it’s a positive that (the Niagara Parks Commission) is going to listen to (Wallenda) again. I can tell you that on this side of the border there is universal support for what he wants to do. We’re all hoping this can happen between the two countries.”
Niagara Parks turned down Wallenda’s request in early December – three weeks after he was allowed to minutes to make a short presentation to commission members at a public meeting.
“Safety and our responsibility to preserve and protect the Falls, and all those who wish to view its beauty, are our paramount concern in reaching the decision we have,” Thomson said at the time, explaining why she and her fellow commissioners couldn’t support Wallenda’s proposal.
“What we’re doing is re-affirming our policy against stunting.”
Stunting – a word Wallenda doesn’t like applied to what he does for a living – was never used during the meeting with Chan, said Niagara Falls MPP Kim Craitor.
“The meeting was more about the economic impact (of the proposed walk) and the safety aspects,” said Craitor, who help arrange the meeting with Chan and was there to show his support for Wallenda’s bid.
A Toronto consultant retained by Wallenda has concluded such a performance would bring $20 million into the local economy on the two sides of the border and millions of viewers worldwide.
Wallenda’s 15-page economic study done by Toronto’s Enigma Research predicted 120,000 people would watch the attempted crossing live and spend an estimated $20.5 million.
That number would balloon to $122 million of ‘legacy spending’ after five years, the report says. This includes money generated by repeat visitors or first-time visitors to Niagara Falls, who would come after viewing the show live, or on news reports or through special programs.
Enigma said a confirmed deal with the Discovery Network would allow the spectacle to be viewed live by more than 400 million people around the world, and at least another 60 million would see it through news broadcasts or entertainment shows.
In addition to going through the potential financial benefits of the proposed walk, Wallenda and his manager explained in detail the many safety measures he’s prepared to put in place should he receive the go-ahead.
Chan said Wallenda told him he did not feel he had enough time to explain his proposal when he appeared before the commission last fall. Compared to the 1 1/2 spent with Chan on Friday, Wallenda’s presentation before the commission was just 12 minutes long and none of the commissioners asked him any questions.
“I myself think the proposal is quite interesting,” said Chan of his meeting with Wallenda. It was “a good, thorough conversation.”
Thomson said she is open to meeting again with Wallenda.
“The minister called me around 11:30 this morning and told me he had heard Mr. Wallenda’s presentation. He said he wouldn’t override the Parks Commission’s decision but he felt that perhaps we hadn’t heard all of Mr. Wallenda’s presentation.”
Thomson said she wasn’t sure what form the meeting would take. It could be inviting him back before the full Commission, it could involve a one-on-one meeting with her, or it could involve Wallenda getting together with general manager Fay Booker and the appropriate technical staff.
Thomson said Wallenda is supposed to get in touch with her, but she might write him a note if she doesn’t hear from him in the next few days.
Wallenda told Bullet News Friday night he wasn’t bothered by the latest statement from the New York Parks.
“My dream has always been to walk between the U.S. and Canada. This quite honestly doesn’t concern me. Things are moving along in a positive direction with the Canadian officials and I am still very optimistic that we will get the proper permission granted very soon.”